
An in-depth ‘teardown’ published this morning by policy-monitoring site Tracked Changes has cast doubt on headline figures the Home Office used to defend a key clause of the Immigration and Asylum Bill that cleared the House of Commons last week. In an analysis dated 22 November, Tracked Changes point-scored a Home Office press release which claimed that “nearly 80 percent” of people who said they were victims of modern slavery while in immigration detention were later found not to be genuine cases. The site compared the press statement with the department’s own ad-hoc data tables—released the previous day—and found that while the 80 percent figure is arithmetically correct, the same tables show a much higher “conclusive grounds” success rate (18 percent) for detainees than the release implied, and more than double that rate (41 percent) for people who make the same claims outside detention. The analysis argues that the press release therefore framed detained referrals as “disproportionately false” without acknowledging the evidential gap. Tracked Changes also examined a new clause inserted at Commons Report Stage that the Home Office says will “scrap” the current five-day notice period before forced removal. It finds that the wording of New Clause 10 actually retains the five-day minimum but extends a separate 21-day window for re-attempting removals to six months—something the Bill’s own 130-page impact assessment, finalised five months earlier, never modelled. The article notes that MPs nevertheless passed the Bill by 290 votes to 94 on 17 November. It now moves to the House of Lords, with peers expected to question both the data underlying the Bill and its widened removal powers when they begin detailed scrutiny next month. For employers moving staff into or out of the UK, the analysis is a reminder that detention-related National Referral Mechanism (NRM) decisions and last-minute asylum claims remain politically sensitive. Corporate mobility teams should watch for further amendments in the Lords that could alter notice periods, detention conditions or appeal rights—factors that can complicate business travel or emergency assignments involving employees who fall out of immigration status.
Source: Tracked Changes